Myelinating oligodendrocytes die in human disease and early in aging. Despite this, the mechanisms that underly oligodendrocyte death are not resolved and it is also not clear whether these mechanisms change as oligodendrocyte lineage cells are undergoing differentiation and maturation. Here, we used a combination of intravital imaging, single-cell ablation, and cuprizone-mediated demyelination, in both female and male mice, to discover that oligodendrocyte maturation dictates the dynamics and mechanisms of cell death. After single-cell phototoxic damage, oligodendrocyte precursor cells underwent programmed cell death within hours, differentiating oligodendrocytes died over several days, while mature oligodendrocytes took weeks to die. Importantly cells at each maturation stage all eventually died but did so with drastically different temporal dynamics and morphological features. Consistent with this, cuprizone treatment initiated a caspase-3–dependent form of rapid cell death in differentiating oligodendrocytes, while mature oligodendrocytes never activated this executioner caspase. Instead, mature oligodendrocytes exhibited delayed cell death which was marked by DNA damage and disruption in poly-ADP-ribose subcellular localization. Thus, oligodendrocyte maturation plays a key role in determining the mechanism of death a cell undergoes in response to the same insult. This means that oligodendrocyte maturation is important to consider when designing strategies for preventing cell death and preserving myelin while also enhancing the survival of new oligodendrocytes in demyelinating conditions.