Investigations on acute carbon monoxide (CO) poisoning struggle to highlight a relevant discriminant criterion related to CO poisoning severity for predicting complications, such as delayed neurological syndromes. In this context, it remains difficult to demonstrate the superiority of one method of oxygen (O2) administration over others or to identify the optimal duration of normobaric 100% oxygen (NBO) treatment. Myoglobin, as hemoglobin, are a potential binding site for CO, which could be a source of extravascular CO storage that impacts the severity of CO poisoning. It is not possible in routine clinical practice to estimate this potential extravascular CO storage. Indirect means of doing so that are available in the first few hours of poisoning could include, for example, the carboxyhemoglobin half-life (COHbt1/2), which seems to be influenced itself by the level and duration of CO exposure affecting this store of CO within the body. However, before the elimination of CO can be assessed, the COHbt1/2 toxicokinetic model must be confirmed: research still debates whether this model mono- or bi-compartmental. The second indirect mean could be the assessment of a potential COHb rebound after COHb has returned to 5% and NBO treatment has stopped. Moreover, a COHb rebound could be considered to justify the duration of NBO treatment. On an experimental swine model exposed to moderate CO poisoning (940 ppm for ±118 min until COHb reached 30%), we first confirm that the COHb half-life follows a bi-compartmental model. Secondly, we observe for the first time a slight COHb rebound when COHb returns to 5% and oxygen therapy is stopped. On the basis of these two toxicokinetic characteristics in favor of extravascular CO storage, we recommend that COHbt1/2 is considered using the bi-compartmental model in future clinical studies that compare treatment effectiveness as a potential severity criterion to homogenize cohorts of the same severity. Moreover, from a general toxicokinetic point of view, we confirm that a treatment lasting less than 6 hours appears to be insufficient for treating moderate CO poisoning.