Optimal surgical management of patients with intractable constipation and diffuse colonic motility is not well defined. We present a patient with such a history, who ultimately achieved successful surgical management of constipation through a stepwise approach. An 8-year-old female presents with longstanding constipation and diffuse colonic dysmotility demonstrated with colonic manometry. She initially underwent sigmoid resection and cecostomy which failed and required diverting ileostomy. We initially proceeded with an extended resection, colonic derotation (Deloyers procedure), and neo-appendicostomy (neo-Malone) which resulted in successful spontaneous stooling for 1 year. Her constipation recurred and she subsequently underwent completion colectomy with ileorectal anastomosis given that she previously demonstrated ability to stool independently. Six months from surgery the patient continues to stool daily with assistance of fiber and loperamide. This case highlights a stepwise surgical approach to managing constipation due to diffuse colonic dysmotility and demonstrates that diffuse dysmotility may benefit from an upfront subtotal resection; however, it is crucial to assess a patient's ability to empty their rectum prior.